1 Comment
User's avatar
barri's avatar

Michael,

I would be interested to know your opinion on this.

Since the Welsh Gender Service (WGS) paused surgeries recently I have seen many activists pointing towards this case "R v. North West Lancashire Health Authority, ex parte A, D, and G)" and saying that the WGS is under a duty to perform these surgeries.

However, when I have looked into this I have found this:

“Illness” is not statutorily defined. Early on in the hearing of this case Mr Clarke for the

Health Authority accepted that gender identity dysphoria (hereinafter GID) fell within the

description of illness as set out in Section 1(1)B of the 1977 Act and thus, that the respondent

Health Authority was under the “duty to continue the promotion … of a comprehensive

health service designed to secure an improvement … in the prevention, diagnosis and

treatment of illness” and thus of GID.

I would like to know if this case is still applicable when "gender identity dysphoria" no longer exists and has been replaced by "gender incongruence" which is not considered an illness.